Padawans request

Mercy

Member since: 2007
Location
Wellington

Sketch for the request by Lord Crumb.

The Zabrak's dress may be a little small. What does everyone think?

Comments

Xanamiar

Well... I have to say.. the dress is definately small.. but it fits with the rules.. don't show more than Leia while in the slave outfit... Looks good...

Lord Crumb

Its' looking great and taking shape! I can not wait to see the finished product. Keep up the good work.

Lord Crumb

Mercy, I am eagerly awaiting your completed piece. I especially liked the way you did the background on your Anime Fargul piece. I was wondering if you could do something similar with a Dantoonie background. If you can not, do not have any worries about it. Just having you take my request and Ghost ITH taking my other request has had me sitting on cloud nine ever since :-)

Mercy

Okay, before I loved Photoshop - now I LOVE Photoshop!
Took a little longer this time and did a full ink layer instead of inking manually. I really like the sharpness you get.

Anyway.
Here's the first colour version. No lightsabers yet, no shadows, no detail except the eyes. This is just to check that the colours are acceptable before I go any further.

Lord Crumb.
Yeah, I liked the effect on the Farghul sketch too. I'll drop a background in that's in a similar style if you like.
Sit back and revel in the request-y goodness!

Lord Crumb

Mercy, you are an angel of art in my book. It is really coming along now that I am seeing it in color :)

If I might make an observation - the hilts on the lightsabers look a little on the short side. Maybe lengthen them just a bit, otherwise it looks great :)

Also, can I get your permission to add the pic to the cover of my short story about the characters.

Eclipse

Mercy,

I hate to be the person always raining on your parade. Your images are beautiful, but your "martial" stances need a bit of work. I don't expect you to go changing them or anything, but I'm going to toss out a few tidbits for reference, and as a frame of reference, my personal experience with martial arts is mostly unarmed, but the basics seem to carry through from one art form to the next.

The basic (forward) stance:

The basic martial arts forward stance is all about legs. The feet should always be shoulder width apart... in fact, if you were to imagine a line connecting the shoulders, use that line on the ground 4 times to create a box on the ground that is equilateral. The character's feet should be on 2 opposing corners of that box. The front leg should be bent with the back leg roughly straight and the hips directly over the center point of our imaginary box on the floor. If you get the angle of the bend on the front leg correct, this will have the happy affect of forcing your lower body to always be proportionate. Also, the front leg's shin area should be perpendicular to the ground, so the thigh is the only thing angled toward the hip area... I hope that makes sense.

Your male character's legs are REALLY close to being a proper stance. His forward leg just needs to move toward the viewer a little bit. It's also noteworthy that in the forward stance, the more "forward" the back foot can face, the more desirable it is. The objective is to have the feet parallel. Most practitioners find this difficult to achieve, so an outward angle on the foot is acceptable. But I'm just throwing out "optimum".

In an actual situation, this stance will get used a LOT. If a character is moving, it should always be his objective to keep the proportions I've outlined here (if he's wanting forward stances). Also, it's of note that two forward stanced character can easily stand back to back. The Zabrak in this pic is pretty close to what we'd call a "Cat Stance".

The "Cat" Stance:

The Cat Stance is primarily used for quick "counter-attacks" and retreat. In a cat stance the hips are directly over one leg (the back leg). The "back" leg is your foundation. It is bent at about a 45 degree angle (ish), and the foot of the back leg is flat on the ground, and pointed in the same direction as your hips. The "front" leg is pointed out perpendicular to the back leg with ball of the foot on the ground, and the leg bent comfortably. Again remember that the entirety of the weight of the body is on the back leg. This allows for quick kicks on an approaching opponent, or allows the front leg to push backwards for a quick retreat.

The basic Horse stance:

The last basic stance is the "horse" stance. This one is the easiest to describe. Feet parallel, 1.5-2 shoulder widths apart, directly out on either side of the body. Leg bent appropriately, although at its widest, a horse stance can actually have the thighs perpendicular to the ground.

I toss this stuff out not as a criticism (because your work rocks) but just as a reference for the future if you find it useful. If you'd like some images to accompany the descriptions, PM me and I'll get them to you in the next day or two.

Hope that's helpful.

Eclipse

Mercy

Thanks for the tips, Eclipse. Yeah, I wasn't originally gonna have them in stance and drew the Zabrak first, then decided to alter her when the human seemed to naturally take up his position. (Ever have that? When a character sort of draws himself...)
Anyway, I kept her stance quite passive, and his more focussed on battle, as this seemed to fit with their characters as described by Lord Crumb.

Seriously, though, I always find your observations helpful and they're always well received. I can already see my artwork improving as a result, and it's due to all the positive and well informed points I get here.

Gotta run now as we've just picked up 'Assassin's Creed' and I'm itchin to play it!

Oh, I'll drop in the background I'll be using.
Also, Lord Crumb - Use the picture how you will when I'm done with it, but I want credit if it's going up outside of here. I'll send you details if that's the case.

Lord Crumb

Thank you Mercy, but other than a few close friends reading the short story I'm writting. It will not be posted on any website or published. Personal use only. But you will get the credit for the picture, you created and made it happen. I do like the background picture you have posted. It looks like Dantoonie to me. Keep up the good work :)

Eclipse

Mercy,

Great! I'm glad you don't take my comments badly. I try to not come off that way. I LOVE the background work you've got going on.

No, unfortunately I've never had a character draw itself, but that's cause I suck at characters. :-) I can't wait to see the finished product on this one.

Eclipse

Mercy

Couldn't help myself - here's the colour version of the background.
Why is art so much fun?! Okay, silly question...

Mercy

And... here's the image with background and lightsabers lit.
I'll start work on the shading and detail for the characters now.

Lord Crumb

Eerin Lumna's (Zabrak female)lightsaber blade looks like it needs to be just a bit longer in length. Lightsaber bladers are generally 3m in length. Looking great :-)

Tramp

Crumb, Lightsaber blades are only one meter in length, not three. Three meters would be over nine feet. A great saber is three meters. I think you mean three feet (just under a meter), but yes, those blades are a bit on the short side.

Lord Crumb

Thanks Tramp, My GOOF. I got 1 meter mixed with the 3.28 feet conversion. Yes, a lightsaber blade is only 1 meter (metre) long. Next time I'll make sure my central processor is within normal operationg parameters. :-)

Mercy

Yeah, it's cool - I figured you meant 3ft or something. Changed it and will post again when I have the shading done. Having looked at it again it is noticable. Should be about as long as the arm, yeah?

Mercy

Okay. Here's the first version of the completed piece. I always end up changing it, though. What do we think?

Tramp

The blades are still a little short. Take a look at some of my Jedi pics. They will give you a good idea of the proper length. The length of the lightsaber blade should be about from the ground to your waist with the handle adding another 24-30 centemeters to that. Thus, the weapon, over-all, is about 4 feet (1.3 meters) from tip to pommel.

Lord Crumb

I'm totally blown away! This is great and I love the shading. You may hate me for this, but could you bring the colored background just to the other side of Liam. :-)

Mercy

Okie-dokie. Here's a copy with the background flipped and the colour on the other side. You do lose the moon behind his head, but what'cha gonna do?

Made the lightsabers bigger again, I hope this is closer to the right length. I'm not very good at the pommels, I know. They just don't look interesting enough. I'll have a play with them, but I think this may be the best we're gonna get.

What do you think?

Lord Crumb

Can you flip it back the way you had it cause that looked better. What I was trying to said was enlarge the color box behind them to include a portion of the house next to Liam. Thank you :-)

Mercy

Right, okay. Here's the background with the colour section enlarged and filled in. I won't be able to make it any bigger without needing to do the whole thing...

I'll work at slipping it into the full picture again next.

Mercy

And... Here it is.

Background changed, lightsabers lengthened again for this version, and I think it's done!

Let me know if anything else needs altering.

Tramp

Not bad, but the lightsabers still need work. Given their current position in the layout, the blade of the girl's should be running off the edge of the page, or pretty close to it As I said, if held vertically, downward,the blade alone should be able to reach the ground from waist height. the blades you made barely reach past her knee from ground level. Measure the entire length of her leg from the sole of her foot to her waist. That is the length her lightsaber blade should be. The hilts should also be twice as long as they currently are. A standard lightsaber can be held in two hands with room to spare. Thus, you need to double the legth of the grips on both sabers.

Mercy

Um, 'Short-sabers'? Like Short-swords? Single handed, shorter blades.
Or am I just being difficult.

I just don't want to unbalance the picture (the stance and grip won't work if the blade is much longer) for the sake of traditional accuracy. Don't get me wrong, I always like getting comments from you guys, but if it is a case of running her saber off the page and his well into the ground in order to be accurate I'd rather not.
I'm gonna re-draw the hilts and try blending them into the picture. I'll post again when this is done.

Tramp

Well, if I were you, I'd have the boy's blade extending from the opposite end it currently is, so that it faces upwards. As for the girl's If you shift them over a little closer to the tree, you could add a bit more length to her blade. Failing that, resize them compared to the background so they're a little smaller. I often do that when I make a background in order to fit the character into his or her surroundings better. The simplest option would be to simply widen your canvas a bit.

Eclipse

Mercy,

OK, tossing out some more martial thoughts that might fix your problem here.

1.) Her had is angled in such a way as to be uncomfortable in comparison with the arm. I didn't take issue with this earlier cause there was really no point. However, if you were to bring her hand back in line (some) with the rest of the arm, then you could essentially keep the blade tip at the same horizontal position on your canvas, and just change its vertical position.

2.) I totally agree with Tramp, I think the male's blade should be coming out of the other end.

For reference, (and I didn't read the request so, if it was specified sorry) fighting with a blade backwards like that is rather uncommon for regular sized weapons. A knife blade or a little longer would be the ideal weapon for that hand hold as the entire point is to cover the forearm as a block. A regular weapon used that way would be uncommon at best... Anyway, just my 2 cents. Choose to do with it what you will.
:-)

Eclipse

Lord Crumb

I'll leave it up to the experts in the art department on the final details of the picture. It does look good in my opinon. I can't draw worth crap compared to the artist on this site. Mercy has no more demands from me.

Mercy

Here's the new (rather more interesting) hilts. I'm worried they're too big now. Damn. This just doesn't seem to be going right at all. I always liked that backwards knife hand-hold, which was part of why I kept the blades short. I'll work on changing his hand position, cause I want to keep the blade where it is. Don't know what I'm gonna do with hers...

Lord Crumb

Eerin's hilt looks fine to me and like the swirl. She is the best drawn Zabrak female I've seen on this site. I know I said no more demands from me but Liam's guards on the hilt need to shorted just a bit. :-)

Eclipse

Mercy,

Don't take it too much one way or another. I mean the whole point of art is art... not "accuracy". I spend a lot of time saying what would or wouldn't be accurate, but you know... if you spend the time to make every piece you do accurate, then you'll end up like me... I've been working on the same damn thing for 4+ years now. I like it, it looks sweet, but you've done more art in the short time you've been here than I have in my entire stay. Don't sweat it too much. Make some hilts you like and move on.

Eclipse

Tramp

The huge flanges on the boy's hilt are a bit much. I'd lose'em. Same with the spirals and wierd "bird neck" shape on the girl's pommel. They wouldn't survive their first battle anywaywithout being sliced off.

Mercy

Thanks Eclipse, and you too Lord Crumb, was feelin' a little despondent. I'm okay though. Sorry if I sounded grumpy.

I've adjusted the guards on Liam's hilt and turned his hand round. Took me a bit of playing with, but I think it's about as good as I can make it at this stage.

So I have to ask - What are you guys doin up at, like, 1:30 in the morning?! It's 7:30 in the evening here and still light outside...

(P.S. Double pages now! Woo-hoo!)

Lord Crumb

I have been watching Torchwood on BBC American and currently watching Battlestar Galactica on Sci-Fi channel. My normal saturday format. It is 12:38 CST in Northeast Mississippi.

Mercy

Ha ha! You guys are crazy!
Sigh. I have to go to work for 7am tomorrow. Bugger.

Oh, I've adjusted the angle of the green saber. Decided it looked like it was too disjointed after changing the hilts. Oh, and that was my first time drawing proper Lightsaber hilts. If they're too flowry for 'real' use, well, I'll know for next time.
Won't bother re-posting the pic as I've filled up rather a lot of space already...

Eclipse

The Wife's birthday is rather soon, and so I found her b-day present for super cheap on friday, so I bought it for her early. Anyway, we've been up catching up on Avatar (The Last Airbender, which is totally awesome) and breaking into her gift (which was the first 2 seasons of Bones). Plus I'm on CST too, and it's just now 1:00am, which is not an uncommon bed-time for me on any day, much less a Saturday night.

Eclipse

Lord Crumb

No more of a geek then the rest of us. Be at peace, passive, calm and let the force flow through your brush. :-)

Mercy

Right, I'm gonna bite the bullet and submit this.
Been good chatting with you guys. 'Till next time!

Mercy

Lord Crumb, if you want a bigger copy of this just let me know and I'll email it to you, okay?

Lord Crumb

I am already thinking of a new request, but I am going to wait a little while before putting in the request.